Lantern Theater Company Presents the Digital Premiere of The Gospel According to Thomas Jefferson, Charles Dickens & Count Leo Tolstoy: Discord by Scott Carter

-Courtesy of Lantern Theater Company

Lantern Theater Company announced today the digital premiere of The Gospel According to Thomas Jefferson, Charles Dickens & Count Leo Tolstoy: Discord – the company’s newest professionally filmed production, furthering its mission to engage audiences with plays that investigate and illuminate what is essential in the human spirit and the spirit of the times. A Founding Father, a Victorian literary celebrity, and a Russian aristocrat/anarchist clash in this provocative comedy that sets three of the world’s greatest thinkers against each other in a battle of wits and wills. Jefferson, Dickens, and Tolstoy find themselves locked in a room with no exit. Attempting an escape, they ransack the philosophies of their lives and work, searching for a truth that will set them free while confronting their own hypocrisy and failings. Created by playwright and former stand-up comedian Scott Carter and directed by Armina LaManna, the production features Gregory Isaac as Jefferson, Brian McCann as Dickens, and Lantern Artistic Director Charles McMahon as Tolstoy. The Gospel According to Thomas Jefferson, Charles Dickens & Count Leo Tolstoy: Discord streams on demand now through December 19, 2021. Tickets and information are available online at

Originally produced by the Lantern during its 2016/17 season, The Gospel According to Thomas Jefferson, Charles Dickens & Count Leo Tolstoy: Discord was written by Scott Carter over the course of many years, following a nearly fatal asthma attack that set him on a path of spiritual exploration. Inspired by Carter’s discovery that Jefferson, Dickens, and Tolstoy had all compiled their own gospels from existing biblical literature, the play explores their aspirations and foibles. Thrust together in death, three of the modern world’s most influential minds grapple in spirited and witty debate about their beliefs and their ability – and failure – to live up to their own God’s standards with nothing but a pen, a journal, and their squabbling roommates to judge them. Carter noted that after his near-death experience he “entered a bliss state – loving all whom I met and forgiving previous transgressions done to me. It lasted about a week.” The Gospel According to Thomas Jefferson, Charles Dickens & Count Leo Tolstoy: Discord is an exploration of the instinct to reach toward grace and the difficulty of living in it. 

“The Lantern has long produced work that engages both the head and the heart, bringing to life explorations of human nature, philosophy, art, and literature,” said Lantern Artistic Director Charles McMahon, who also plays Tolstoy in the filmed production. “This play forces Jefferson, Dickens, and Tolstoy to confront the serious problems undermining their legacies and to ask whether the good they intended through their public actions excuse the real harms done to the people over whom they had power and sway.” 

Director Armina LaManna met and talked with Carter throughout the process of rehearsing and filming his play. “To Scott, this play is like a living, breathing entity,” she said. “I really liked the play when I read it. When I met him, that changed into a more intimate relationship for me, because of the way that he talked about it. And the skill and the erudition that he used to write this play is absolutely stunning. Scott really, really wants his play to change people.” 

Lantern Theater Company will further explore The Gospel According to Thomas Jefferson, Charles Dickens & Count Leo Tolstoy: Discord on its Lantern Searchlight blog, available online at Published articles will delve into the history of Jefferson, Dickens, and Tolstoy and their gospels, plus behind the scenes interviews with the artists. New content will be added throughout the play’s streaming run. 

Tickets for The Gospel According to Thomas Jefferson, Charles Dickens & Count Leo Tolstoy: Discord are $20 per household/device and are available online at or by calling the Lantern Box Office at (215) 829-0395. Closed captioning is available. Ticket buyers will receive an email confirmation with their ticket access link, which will provide on-demand access to the playfor one viewing during the November 9 – December 19, 2021 streaming period. The production can be viewed on most internet-connected devices with email/web browser access, including desktops, laptops, tablets, smartphones, and select smart TVs. The Lantern Box Office will be accessible by phone and email for extended hours throughout the streaming period to provide assistance. A Digital Dickens Pass is also available for $35, which includes one ticket for The Gospel According to Thomas Jefferson, Charles Dickens & Count Leo Tolstoy: Discord and the filmed version of the Lantern’s original production of Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol (streaming December 14, 2021 – January 2, 2022). 

About the Artists 
Playwright and former stand-up comic Scott Carter served as executive producer and writer for the first 1,100 episodes of Politically Incorrect and the first 18 seasons of Real Time with Bill Maher. He has been nominated for 24 Primetime Emmy Awards and has won multiple PGA and WGA Awards. He also served as creator, producer, and/or writer for Root of All Evil with Lewis Black (Comedy Central), Earth to America (TBS), and The Conspiracy Zone with Kevin Nealon (Spike). The Gospel According to Thomas Jefferson, Charles Dickens & Count Leo Tolstoy: Discord has been produced in 27 cities in four countries. 

Director Armina LaManna returns to Philadelphia, where her world premiere translation/co-adaptation of Nikolai Gogol’s The Government Inspector was produced as part of the Lantern’s 2008/09 season. A graduate of Temple University, LaManna is the founding artistic director of Imagine Theatre, the only Equity theater in LA County focused on theater for young audiences. 

Reprising their roles from the Lantern’s original 2017 production are Gregory Isaac and Brian McCann as Thomas Jefferson and Charles Dickens, respectively.  

Isaac’s Lantern credits include The Resistible Rise of Arturo UiBetrayal, and next season’s mainstage productions of Fabulation, or the Re-Education of Undine and A Man for All Seasons. Other local credits include productions with Quintessence Theatre Group, 1812 Productions, and Delaware Shakespeare; he was a 2017 Barrymore Award nominee for his work as Achilles in Iphigenia at Aulis with the Philadelphia Artists’ Collective. National credits include productions with the Goodman Theatre, Steppenwolf Theatre, The Alliance Theatre, and Chicago Shakespeare Theater.  

McCann’s Lantern credits include CoriolanusRomeo & JulietHappy DaysTravels with My AuntOthelloKing Lear, and The Lady from the Sea. Other regional credits include McCarter Theatre Center, Delaware Theatre Company, Pennsylvania Shakespeare Festival, George Street Playhouse, 1812 Productions, the Philadelphia Artists’ Collective, and Arden Theatre Company. 

Charles McMahon joins the cast as Leo Tolstoy. McMahon founded Lantern Theater Company in 1994 and serves as artistic director in addition to directing, writing, and acting for the company. He has directed all but one of the Lantern’s annual Shakespeare productions, including recent productions of Othello (shuttered after one preview performance in March 2020 due to Covid-19), Measure for MeasureThe Tempest, and Coriolanus. Other Lantern directing credits include The Resistible Rise of Arturo UiAs You Like ItThe Taming of the ShrewHenry VNew JerusalemRomeo & JulietA Midsummer Night’s DreamHamletLa Ronde (also translator and adapter), Richard IIIThe Comedy of ErrorsMuch Ado About NothingKing LearThe House of Bernarda Alba, and A Doll’s House. Recent acting credits include reprising the role of Heisenberg in Copenhagen, and writing credits include Oscar Wilde: From the Depths and co-creating an original adaptation of Dylan Thomas’ A Child’s Christmas in Wales

The returning design team for The Gospel According to Thomas Jefferson, Charles Dickens & Count Leo Tolstoy: Discord includes scenic designer Lance Kniskern, costume designer Millie Hiibel, lighting designer Shon Causer alongside new co-lighting designer Isabella Gill-Gomez, and sound designer and composer Christopher Colucci. Lantern Artistic Associate Hannah Spear was assistant director and longtime Lantern Stage Manager Rebecca Smith was the associate producer. 

About Lantern Theater Company 
Founded in 1994 and now in its 28th season, Lantern Theater Company’s mission is to produce plays that investigate and illuminate what is essential in the human spirit and the spirit of the times. The Lantern serves the Philadelphia region with artistic and educational programming, notably partnering with middle schools and high schools in the Philadelphia School District to provide in-classroom residencies in support of curricular learning. Throughout the Covid-19 health crisis, the Lantern has continued to provide artistic programming on both a free and paid basis, including readings of Shakespeare plays in spring 2020; filmed versions of fully realized theatrical productions of Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol in December 2020 and Molly Sweeney by Brian Friel in January-March 2021; and this spring’s Plays from the Lantern Archives series, which included professionally filmed and edited versions of its 2017 world premiere production of The Craftsman by Bruce Graham and three recent Shakespeare productions: Measure for Measure (2019), The Tempest (2018), and Coriolanus (2017). 

In addition to The Gospel According to Thomas Jefferson, Charles Dickens & Count Leo Tolstoy: Discord, the Lantern’s 2021 Digital Season continues with the newly filmed American premiere production of The Plague by Neil Bartlett, adapted from La Peste by Albert Camus and extended through November 21, 2021; and the world premiere digital production of Me and the Devil, co-written and directed by Steve H. Broadnax III and streaming on demand now through November 21, 2021. In its recently announced 2021/22 Mainstage Season, the Lantern will return to live performance in December 2021 with its original adaptation of Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol, co-created by theater artists Anthony Lawton, Christopher Colucci, and Thom Weaver, followed by the Philadelphia premiere of two-time Pulitzer Prize-winner Lynn Nottage’s satirical Fabulation, or the Re-Education of Undine, the Philadelphia professional premiere of Robert Bolt’s award-winning classic A Man for All Seasons, Tom Stoppard’s Tony Award-winning comic masterpiece Travesties, and a fourth play to be announced soon. 

More information about the Lantern is available online at

$20 per household/device 
$35 Digital Dickens Pass, which includes access to digital productions of The Gospel According to Thomas Jefferson, Charles Dickens & Count Leo Tolstoy: Discord and Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol 

Closed captioning is available for all digital productions 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.